Add it up some slow morning. Angi takes a bite every month. Google LSA (that's Local Services Ads, the little badge at the top of the search page) takes another. The truck wrap ran you a couple grand and you're still paying it down. Yard signs, the magnet you handed out at the fair, the Little League banner. Round it off and you're spending somewhere between a few hundred and a couple thousand a month just to make the phone ring.
Now the hard question. Which one of those is actually booking work, and which one is just sending you tire-kickers who want a number over the phone and then vanish? You don't know. Be honest. You're guessing, same as every other truck on the road.
Guessing costs you twice. You keep feeding the channel that's quietly bleeding you, and you starve the one that books real jobs because you can't see it's the winner. The fix is dead simple, and it starts with one question.
Ask "How'd you find us?" every single time
Every call, every text, every web form, you ask one line: how'd you find us? Takes four seconds. They'll tell you Angi, or "saw your truck on the Pike," or "my neighbor had you do their roof." That last one is a referral, and it's usually your cheapest, best work. You want to know exactly how many of those you're getting.
Make it the rule for anybody who answers your phone, not just you. If your spouse books calls at night or an answering service catches the overflow, they ask it too. One missing answer is one blind spot in the month.
One catch. A lot of folks say "Google" when they mean the LSA ad, or "the internet" when they mean your website. Ask a tiny follow-up when it's fuzzy: "Google, or did you see us somewhere first?" You don't need a life story. You need the channel.
You won't remember. Nobody does.
Here's where this falls apart for most trades. You ask the question, the homeowner answers, and then you're onto the job and it's gone from your head by lunch. Forty calls a week, and you're reconstructing it all from memory at the end of the month. That data's garbage.
Log it the second you hear it. Not later, not tonight. The channel only sticks if it lands somewhere the moment the words leave their mouth.
A few ways that actually hold up on a busy week:
- The "lead source" box in your scheduling or invoicing app. Most have one. Use it.
- A shared note on your phone the whole crew can add to.
- A quick text to a dedicated number that logs the source alongside the job.
- A clipboard by the phone in the shop, if that's honestly how you run.
Let the tally run itself
Once a month, you want that pile of answers turned into a scorecard. This is where a simple AI setup earns its keep. It reads every logged lead, sorts them by source, and matches them against which ones actually turned into booked jobs. You get a one-page answer instead of a shoebox of notes you'll never add up by hand.
Lead count by itself will lie to you. A channel can flood you with twenty calls and book two of them. Another sends six and books four. The one sending fewer calls is quietly crushing it, and raw lead count hides that completely.
Cost per booked job is the only number that counts
Pair every source with two things: what you spent on it, and what it booked. Then do the division. Rough example, and these are made-up round numbers just to show the shape of it:
- Angi: 18 leads, 2 booked, about $600 spent. That's roughly $300 a job.
- Google LSA: 7 leads, 4 booked, about $400 spent. Call it $100 a job.
- Truck wrap: 3 leads, 2 booked, and the wrap's basically paid off. Nearly free work at this point.
Stare at that and the whole picture flips. The channel throwing the most calls at you (Angi, in this made-up case) is your most expensive work per booked job. The quiet ones are carrying the month. The money move is simple: stop ranking channels by how loud they are, and start ranking them by what a real job costs you.
Be honest about what the numbers can't see
This is where you slow down. Truck wraps and yard signs are slow burns. Somebody sees your truck forty times over a year and finally calls in the spring, and they'll just say "I see you around." You can't pin that to one month, and you shouldn't axe the wrap because March was quiet.
Referrals get miscredited too. A neighbor recommends you, the homeowner Googles your name to find the number, and now it logs as "Google" when word of mouth did the real work. The question helps and a follow-up helps more, but it's not perfect. Know that going in.
And one month is a small sample. Give any channel a real season, sixty to ninety days, before you call it a loser. A single slow stretch isn't proof of anything except a slow stretch.
Worth doing this week
None of this takes a system overhaul. Start here:
- Add a "how'd you find us?" line to every call and text, starting tomorrow. Tell the crew why it matters.
- Pick one spot to log the answer the instant you hear it. One spot, not five.
- Write down what each channel costs you per month. Angi, LSA, the wrap payment, the signs, all of it.
- At month's end, match sources to booked jobs and figure cost per booked job. Let a tool tally it if the pile's big.
- Give it two or three months before you cut anything. Then cut the worst and feed the best.
If wiring up the monthly tally sounds like one more thing you'll never get to, that's the sort of setup we handle for crews around here at Mass AI Agency. Either way, start asking the question. You can't fix what you're not measuring.